So I know the flame green Fireline has been walloping the bass and crappie for me this fall. I also know the new red PowerPro was doing a good job on the crappie yesterday. Only thing left to do was to compare the two against each other on my local bass lake. I got that done Saturday afternoon.
Only two rods in the boat today, both spinning outfits with the two lines mentioned spooled up and each tied directly to identical jigs. I ran almost all new water today so that any bass I encountered weren't already negatively conditioned to the flame green line from previous catches. Today's tough conditions: clear blue sky, SSW winds at 8-15 mph, water temp. at 48 degrees and very clear water for this reservoir, nearly 6' or better. Air temps in the mid-50's.
I started with the flame green outfit until I caught a few bass and would then set it down and pick up the other (red PP) outfit. I'd continue to throw the red PP for a few more fish and then switch off again. If I went for more than 15 minutes without a bite I'd automatically switch rods again. I counted total fish today, and paid attention to general size and numbers relative to line color caught on. This went on for the entire afternoon, fishing from about 1:00 PM until 5:30 PM.
Total bass caught for the trip today was 53, so I got a good set of numbers to base my opinion on. And the winning line was...
...A tie! In all honesty, line color and type didn't seem to make any difference. I caught just as many quality fish on both outfits, as well as many smaller fish on each. Overall numbers were very comparable also. I never broke off a single fish, so line durability was equally good. There is a definite visual advantage for the angler using the flame green line, but even in the clear water conditions with the sunny skies I had today, bass didn't seem to care about that extra visibility. The red PP could be easily seen against some backgrounds, but not so easily seen against others. Neither line seemed to confer any "feel" advantage, both being crappy when slack and great when taut.
So take whatever message you want from this little test. Nearly 200 bass in November on the colored super lines has me believing that at least on the limited lakes I've been fishing, bass could care less. If the superlines fit into your tackle profile, then go ahead and use any of them you want, and don't worry too much about their color or having to tie on leaders to avoid spooking bass.
Words of Wisdom
I was filing through some of my notes the other day when I came across a short note I had received from Greg Mangus many years back. For those that don't know him, Greg is without a doubt one of the best bass anglers in the state - has been for more than two decades now. We've spoken numerous times over the years, and I've had the pleasure of fishing with Greg up on the St. Joe River. Lots of guys would love to know what makes Greg so damn good, myself included at the time, so I asked him. I've been sitting on this little piece of self-reflection for nearly six years now, so hopefully he won't mind me sharing with readers what he had to say.
Permalink | Comments (2)
Reblog (0) | |